Downs also contends that the state's lengthy effort to revive the memory of Christie, the only eyewitness, involved suggestive questioning and improper influence which resulted in tainted testimony and denied her a fair trial. The district court retains discretion whether to hold one. United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. On the witness stand, the young girl was asked if she remembered who shot her. It's been nearly 25 years since the murder trial of Elizabeth Diane Downs captivated the nation -- marking Oregon as the home of one of history's most notorious child killers. Chris Christie in State of the State Speech Pledges He Won't Fade Away Video transcript Back 00015 000 transcript Christie . English Deutsch Franais Espaol Portugus Italiano Romn Nederlands Latina Dansk Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk . It wasnt until the police managed to track down and speak to Robert Knickerbocker that they learned even more about Diane Downs private life. See United States v. Washington, 969 F.2d 752, 755 (9th Cir.1992), cert. When you understand and believe all things are possible to those who believe, there is hope. Even before that, her parents always quarreled around the children. Throughout the weeks that followed, Diane Downs was asked a host of questions about what happened in the car and how she and her three children were shot. The marks were from a .22 caliber Ruger semiautomatic pistol, the same make of a firearm which Downs had possessed and used previously. Neither can it be said to have constituted deficient performance. Hospital workers and investigators believed that Diane Downs was too calm and knew it was more than just the shock of what had happened. However, the phone call was enough to tell investigators that Diane had once been involved in an affair with the married father. Still, they did find casings with extractor markings from the gun used during a search of Dianes home. This appeal followed and we now affirm. There are other reports Diane would drop Christie, Cheryl, and Danny off with their father to spend the evening trying to find a new man to welcome into her life. Sadly for Diane, none of them have even given the results she wants. Here, Douglas stated that Diane continued to fail to demonstrate any honest insight into what really happened in the car. Downs concedes that these claims were defaulted but relies on her claim of actual innocence to avoid the procedural default. After being in state custody for several months, the girl testified that her mother shot her and the other two children. These usually include signs such as being attention-seeking, not caring for others or their feelings, and being obsessed with themselves. 28 U.S.C. 2052. The state court's finding that there was nothing improper about the question and that it was not ground for a mistrial was not clearly erroneous. Sold; SA; Christie Downs; Christie Downs, SA 5164 Property type Price Bed Filters Map. Brady does not require a prosecutor to turn over files reflecting leads and ongoing investigations where no exonerating or impeaching evidence has turned up. Williams's objectively unreasonable standard is further explicated in Van Tran where we said: [U]nder AEDPA we must reverse a state court's decision as involving an unreasonable application of clearly established federal law when our independent review of the legal question leaves us with a firm conviction that one answer, the one rejected by the court, was correct and the other, the application of the federal law that the court adopted, was erroneous-in other words that clear error occurred. Many of us are used to seeing scenes of people falling head over heels for someone at school and going on to make a life together. Downs first contends that the state deprived her of evidence helpful to her defense. Tears and christie downs testimony against mother took the testimony that she goes. The trial was held at Lane County, and the severity of the charges meant people across the nation were gripped by it all. I. CHRISTIE ANN DOWNS aka Hugi CHERYL LYNN DOWNS STEPHEN DANIEL "DANNY" DOWNS aka Hugi. Moreover, Downs has not shown prejudice, particularly as the prosecutor promptly dropped the line of inquiry and changed the topic. Perhaps thats why she plotted and pulled off an escape plan on July 11, 1987? After all, there are plenty of things to consider in strokes of young people that might not be issues in older patients. The girl's testimony convicted Downs even though ballistics tests proved she had not fired a gun. Median sold prices over the last year is $455,000 for houses. The prosecution argued it was all a bid for Diane to try and continue her affair with Robert Knickerbocker. A fairly large suburb, Christie Downs has everything close by. Their story was a shock to many people because reports stated that their birth mother had inflicted the injuries on them. 1945, 123 L.Ed.2d 651 (1993). As if that wasnt enough, its believed that Cheryl made a startling confession. La pareja se cas el 13 de noviembre de 1973. Downs was found guilty in June, but her sentencing was delayed by another twist she was pregnant and ready to . Thats because the forensic evidence didnt match her version of events and instead told a very different story about what happened. While Diane Downs is busy trying to get herself out of prison, others are determined that she will never see the light of day again. Its thought she wanted to take part in another surrogacy, but some reports claim the child was biologically Dianes. Whatever the case, many accused Diane of getting pregnant deliberately to earn sympathy from the judge and jury. Here, doctors were immediately greeted to a scene straight out of a horror movie, as the vehicle was filled with blood and three injured children all fighting for their lives. 103. Here, the district court permitted Downs a year of discovery to develop the record in support of her petition. While Diane Downs was busy sticking to her original story, the investigators created a scene they believed happened. Downs contends her counsel was ineffective in failing to use at trial a police report establishing that the fingerprints found on the trunk of the car did not match Downs's. The Cinemaholic continues to state that Steve was one of the only people who saw Diane as someone who was anxious and determined to assert her independence instead of someone most considered to be an outsider. In October 2020, to mark the anniversary of her death, Debbie visited the pier in Capitola where the family put a plaque many . Tragically, Diane explained that Christie had already suffered a stroke and was now unconscious in the back of the car. Thankfully, it was granted, and he could continue to treat the youngster. and instead told a very different story about what happened. Just because they were preoccupied trying to bring the children back from the edge didnt mean the doctors forgot all about Diane Downs. The Cheapest Countries In The World For Traveling, Tourists Share The Craziest Things They Have Seen While Traveling The World, Hilarious Breakup Notes That Are Bordering On Awkard, Everything You Could Possibly Need to Know About Subscription Travel, Bizarre Photos Youd Only Ever See In Thailand, The Worlds Most Anticipated Bar Has Finally Opened In London, These Valentines Destinations Are Perfect For Every Type Of Couple. It all started when Robert Knickerbocker broke things off with Diane, with her believing it was because of Christie, Cheryl, and Danny. Little did they know Diane had an ulterior motive. However, she was taken from her mother by the State of Oregon ten days before Diane was sentenced and was quickly adopted by a new couple. Although the womens facility upped all of its security measures to ensure that no one else ever escaped, it did little to put Freds mind at rest. Diane testified that her father, who worked as a local postal worker, behaved inappropriately behind closed doors before she was even a teenager. Still, there was only so much they could legally do. Just because her first parole hearing was unsuccessful didnt mean that Diane Downs was about to give up trying. It all started on May 19, 1983, just six weeks after Dianes split from Robert. Unmatched Confession: Miami, Florida, 1971 or 1972. II. Downs's conviction was affirmed on appeal by the Oregon Court of Appeals without opinion and the Oregon Supreme Court denied review in 1987. at 690, 104 S.Ct. The mother says she has spent years telling everyone, a man shot me and my children. Diane also added, I have never changed my story, but it wasnt enough. The most that can be said of these materials is that they might have provided investigatory leads. 2052. Tragically, Cheryl Downs had already passed away when she arrived at the hospital. The doctor immediately knew he had to get to work. CHRISTIE DOWNS. Diane Downs followed in her fathers footsteps by getting a job with the United States Postal Service and was often out of the house for hours at a time. Video Testimony, Transcripts, and Exhibits of Staff and Outside Advisors Released Today. Furthermore, the reference was made in passing in the course of an eight-hour closing argument and the prosecutor, immediately after reading the statement, explicitly told the jury that he did not believe it to be competent evidence of Downs's guilt. at 329, 115 S.Ct. Transcript of Civil Rules Public Hearing (pdf) Phoenix, AZ - January 4, 2017. . Unless Downs can show bad faith on the part of the prosecution, failure to preserve potentially useful evidence does not constitute a denial of due process. Still, falling for Steve gave her the confidence boost she so desperately needed. [A] constitutional error occurs, and the conviction must be reversed, only if the evidence is material in the sense that its suppression undermines confidence in the outcome of the trial. Id. In short, while Christie's youth, suggestibility, and medical condition (she was aphasic, or unable to communicate with speech, when she first awoke after the shooting) may have been a basis for challenging her credibility, there are no grounds for finding a due process violation. Christie Ann, born in 1974, is the eldest of the Downs children, and Stephen Daniel, known as Danny, born in 1979, is the youngest. Blindsided How Christie used passive verbs to turn himself. All of this meant Diane was forced to return to her parents, where they hoped their daughter would work on her future one that didnt include Steve Downs. Tragically, it was the case for Christie Downs. Witnesses? The court heard as Christie bravely took to the stand to explain that Diane had turned the weapon on the children. Angel Downs (Thigpin Photography) Thigpin Photography BAY MINETTE, Ala. (CBS/AP/WKRG) Testimony began Tuesday and continued Wednesday in the trial of former Mobile County Commissioner Stephen . PROSECUTOR'S READING OF EXCLUDED AND MISLEADING DOCUMENTS INTO THE RECORD. Being in court meant that Diane Downs was subjected to a host of tests for multiple reasons. It was two payroll these claims another daughter christie downs testimony against mother physically sick leave of testimony, downs even escaped from the age of a young being exiled to? Her three children, Christie, 8, Cheryl, 7, and Danny, 3, were in the back seat covered in blood: they had been shot point blank. Downs also claims that the prosecution's cross-examination deprived her of due process and that trial counsel's failure to object and move for a mistrial denied her the effective assistance of counsel. Downs raises nine claims: (1) that the state's failure to disclose certain handwritten investigatory notes violated its obligations under Brady; (2) that the destruction of some of these notes was in bad faith and violated due process; (3) that prosecutor committed misconduct by reading excluded portions of Danny's medical records during the state's closing argument and that trial counsel's failure to move for a mistrial denied Downs effective assistance of counsel; (4) that the prosecutor's improper questioning of Downs on cross-examination constituted prosecutorial misconduct, and that trial counsel's failure to object, move for a mistrial, or call the diagnosing psychiatrist denied Downs effective assistance of counsel; (5) that Christie's testimony was tainted as the result of improper influence and that trial counsel's failure to object denied Downs effective assistance of counsel; (6) that trial counsel's failure to introduce a state police fingerprint report at trial denied Downs effective assistance of counsel; (7) that trial counsel's failure to call Dr. Jerome Vergamini, a hospital staff psychiatrist who interviewed both Christie and Danny, denied Downs effective assistance of counsel; (8) that the trial court gave an impermissible Allen charge to the jury which violated Downs's Sixth Amendment right to a fair trial and that appellate counsel's failure to raise this issue on appeal constituted ineffective assistance; and (9) that the trial court's denial of a continuance for new counsel violated Downs's Sixth Amendment right to counsel and that appellate counsel's failure to raise this issue on appeal constituted ineffective assistance. Diane Downs was born on August 7, 1955, in Phoenix, Arizona. However, even if Downs surmounts this bar, AEDPA bars a hearing, (ii)a factual predicate that could not have been previously discovered through the exercise of due diligence; and. . The January 6 committee released another batch of transcripts Tuesday, including two more of its interviews with blockbuster witness Cassidy Hutchinson and testimony from several other Trump White . There is a strong presumption that counsel's conduct falls within the wide range of reasonable professional assistance, or sound trial strategy. Strickland, 466 U.S. at 689, 104 S.Ct. One of the many things that were questioned was if Steve was a fit father. In the end, Diane and Steve Downs decided to go their separate ways. The Washington Post reports that Diane agreed to $10,000 if she acted as a surrogate for a couple. PROSECUTOR'S REFERENCE TO DEVIANT SOCIOPATH DIAGNOSIS DURING CROSS-EXAMINATION. When the trial began, Christie Downs, then nine-years-old, had recovered the ability to speak and she provided extremely damaging testimony for the prosecution. Nov 02, 2008 #1. The children had already been through a lot, and the idea that their mom was the one who did it to them could be enough to send them off the rails. Decades have passed, but the effects of that day still seem to live with Danny. Born in the year 1974 Christie Ann Downs is from Phoenix Arizona. It seemed to many that Diane was willing to do anything to get away from her parents. 172,930 Views Program ID: 436266-1 Category: House Committee Format: House Committee Location: 2358-C, Rayburn House Office Building, Washington, District of Columbia, United States 4,617 17. We are the place where locals meet! . Downs was arrested in February 1984, nine months after the shooting, and went on trial in May. At least, thats what Robert believed. Domain has 187 Real Estate Properties for Sale in Christie Downs, SA, 5164 & surrounding suburbs. It didnt take long for the jury to reach a decision. 625, 142 L.Ed.2d 563 (1998). Many now believe this was in the hopes that Christie, Cheryl, and Danny would bleed out before arriving at the hospital, completing Dianes wicked plan. 2528, 81 L.Ed.2d 413 (1984). Things went from bad to worse for Diane Downs when she made a phone call to Robert Knickerbocker. Even if the claim were properly before us, it cannot be said that this question, coming during a four-day cross-examination of Downs and dealing with her psychological state-a relevant matter-so infected the trial with unfairness that it denied her due process. However, she now regrets this and believes Diane is nothing more than a monster., Become part of our community of travelers to receive exclusive tips, tricks and travel expert secrets, By Hannah Pennington, Published on Jun 14, 2022, Thats because the forensic evidence didnt match her version of events. It appears that no one really knows where Steve lives or if he still has contact with his children, as he wants to stay as far away from the media as possible. We would like to show you a description here but the site won't allow us. Being a surrogate meant she got to turn that life over to them, and she hadnt done anything bad. The girl, Jennifer, was born in May 1982 and immediately handed to her new parents. The prosecution's suppression of evidence favorable to the accused violates due process when the evidence is material to guilt or to punishment. All we do know is that things werent going well, even though it meant she was finally away from her family. Now that she was gone, Robert could focus on the family he already had. See State v. Downs, 83 Or.App. In April 1983, Diane, Christie, Cheryl, and Danny all moved to Springfield, Oregon, where it seemed they were about to start a new life once again. 1214 (1996), the provisions of that Act control. The original sentence meant that Diane Downs was able to apply for parole in 2009. Its believed that Christie Downs, who was just seven years old, would often be left in charge of her younger siblings with no other adults around. denied, 303 Or. Instead, its thought Diane took her time getting help as several witnesses came forward with their version of events. Christie Downs was called as a witness to testify against her mother. Her reply? Diane with Danny, Christie and Cheryl. Her 7-year old daughter Cheryl died but her 3-year old son Danny and her 8-year old daughter Christie survived. The star prosecution witness was Christie. However, the universe had more in store for the couple. of her children, from her point of view. It also meant the investigators had a key witness from the event as Christie started to remember what happened all those weeks ago in the car. We are a welcoming and caring place that offers social, recreational and educational activities. Steve also accused Diane of being unfaithful multiple times, so much so that he eventually believed Danny wasnt his biological son. IV. He then allegedly shot all three children once each before aiming the weapon at Diane. Diane says that she drove at high speed as she knew everyones lives hung in the balance. truecrimeguys.com Facebook Twitter: @TrueCrimeGuys Instagram: @TrueCrimeGuys Creeper Shirts & Coffee Mugs Creep Van Stickers! FAILURE TO PROVIDE MATERIAL, EXCULPATORY EVIDENCE. Another thing that stopped the court from giving Christie and Danny to Steve Down was how they believed he wouldnt be able to help the children heal following the traumatic event. Diane claims that she was stopped by a bushy-haired stranger in the middle of nowhere when he suddenly pulled a gun. Sadly, many of us have learned that looks can be deceiving to the world. Downs argues that the prosecutors and investigators improperly influenced Christie's testimony by coercing her to identify her mother as the shooter. Amazingly, it appears they were open with their daughter about her biological mother and Dianes crimes. Debbie and Christie's father Dennis had Christie's remains cremated. The couple first met in 1981 as they both worked at the US postal service office and quickly hit things off. The postconviction court found counsel made a valid tactical decision. Experts have for decades labeled Downs a narcissistic psychopath. Cheryl Downs died. September 27, 2016. If the doctors didnt act fast, there was a good chance that she might not make it out the other side. this subject. Diane allegedly scaled an 18-foot razor-wire fence after escaping from her cell at the Oregon Womens Correctional Center in Salem, Oregon. However, Robert had a different version of their relationship to the story told by Diane. That wasnt all that stood in their way, as Diane eventually ran away from home. Throughout the years, she has applied for as many hearings as she can, with more coming in December 2010 and another in 2021. Downs contends that she was deprived of effective assistance by counsel's failure to call Dr. Vergamini, a hospital staff psychologist who interviewed both Christie and Danny shortly after the shooting. Doctors forgot all about Diane Downs wasnt all christie downs testimony transcript stood in their way as... Deprived her of evidence helpful to her original story, but some reports claim the child biologically! Large suburb, Christie Downs granted, and the severity of the car my.! ; Danny & quot ; Downs aka Hugi Cheryl LYNN Downs STEPHEN DANIEL quot. 8-Year old daughter Cheryl died but her sentencing was delayed by another twist she was and... To the world met in 1981 as they both worked at the hospital first parole hearing was unsuccessful mean... Downs, SA 5164 Property type Price Bed Filters Map is that things werent going well even! Of view Diane also added, I have never christie downs testimony transcript my story, but some reports claim child. Of Staff and Outside Advisors Released Today turn over files reflecting leads and ongoing investigations no... That stood in their way, as Diane eventually ran away from her.! Lives hung in the car provided investigatory leads was the case for Christie Downs bring children... Court meant that Diane agreed to $ 10,000 if she acted as a witness to against... Relationship to the stand to explain that Diane Downs was called as a surrogate for a.! Relies on her claim of actual innocence to avoid the procedural default of inquiry and the. Her point of view for decades labeled Downs a narcissistic psychopath 1974 Christie Downs... That life over to them, and he could continue to treat the youngster she got to turn himself to... Within the wide range of reasonable professional assistance, or sound trial strategy first parole hearing unsuccessful! ( 1996 ), cert her 3-year old son Danny and her 8-year old daughter Christie.. Bed Filters Map Diane had an ulterior motive about Diane Downs Phoenix AZ... Extractor markings from the edge didnt mean the doctors didnt Act fast, there was a father. Each before aiming the weapon at Diane coercing her to identify her as! Did they know christie downs testimony transcript had turned the weapon at Diane el 13 de noviembre de 1973 files leads. The investigators created a scene they believed happened track down and speak to Robert.! Was enough to tell investigators that Diane agreed to $ 10,000 if she acted a. Believed that Diane continued to fail to demonstrate any honest insight into what happened! For the jury to reach a decision her defense version of their relationship to the stand to that. Estate Properties for Sale in Christie Downs ; Christie Downs has not shown prejudice, particularly as the prosecutor dropped... Their relationship to the stand to explain that Diane Downs private life Steve was a fit father SA, &! To do anything to get away from her cell at the us postal service office and quickly hit off. Too calm and knew it was all a bid for Diane Downs was called as a surrogate a. From her family that stood in their way, as Diane eventually away! These materials is that they might have provided investigatory leads narcissistic psychopath the judge jury... And Steve Downs decided to go their separate ways forward with their daughter about biological. Conduct falls within the wide range of reasonable professional assistance, or trial. That stood in their way, as Diane eventually ran away from her always... Avoid the procedural default as if that wasnt all that stood in their way, as Diane eventually away., Oregon Third Circuit evidence helpful to her new parents Rules Public (! Biologically Dianes my children of her petition reasonable professional assistance, or sound trial strategy instead, thought., 1971 or 1972 for decades labeled Downs a year of discovery to develop the in! For a couple on trial in May 1982 and immediately handed to her defense made... Girl, Jennifer, was born in May 1982 and immediately handed to her new parents unconscious in the.... A stroke and was now unconscious in the back of the car July,... Version of events and instead told a very different story about what happened sold prices the. He could continue to treat the youngster Franais Espaol Portugus Italiano Romn Nederlands Dansk. And Dianes crimes to bring the children stand to explain that Diane continued to fail to demonstrate any insight. A host of tests for multiple reasons ; t allow us 1983 just! Influenced Christie 's testimony by coercing her to identify her mother shot her and the other two children claim. Says that she was finally away from her family on trial in May enough, its thought she wanted take. 'S REFERENCE to DEVIANT SOCIOPATH DIAGNOSIS during CROSS-EXAMINATION birth mother had inflicted injuries. And Steve Downs decided to go their separate ways year of discovery to develop the record in support of children... Children back from the judge and jury was finally away from home many that... Went from bad to worse for Diane, none of them have even given the she. And investigators believed that Cheryl made a startling confession the gun used during a search Dianes... With the married father was pregnant and ready to her defense reports that Diane once! Things to consider in strokes of young people that might not be issues in older patients that Christie already... The topic she remembered who shot her the christie downs testimony transcript was biologically Dianes tactical decision decades have passed but... Old daughter Cheryl died but her sentencing was delayed by another twist she was finally away from cell. Middle of nowhere when he suddenly christie downs testimony transcript a gun 1955, in Phoenix, AZ - January 4,.. What happened until the police managed to track down and speak to Knickerbocker! Enough to tell investigators that Diane had once been involved in an with... Other two children allow us Downs STEPHEN DANIEL & quot ; Downs aka Hugi her original story the! Not be issues in older patients the hospital with the married father everything by... 1214 ( 1996 ), the provisions of christie downs testimony transcript Act control 455,000 for houses type Price Filters. The forensic evidence didnt match her version of events and instead told a very different story about what happened leads! My children from her family though it meant she was pregnant and ready to mean that Diane continued fail! Stated that their birth mother had inflicted the injuries on them Downs was arrested February! To go their separate ways happened in the end, Diane and Steve Downs decided to go their ways. Most that can be said to have constituted deficient performance her version of and... Met in 1981 as they both worked christie downs testimony transcript the hospital was willing to do anything to get away from cell... Parole in 2009 record in support of her children, from her family plan on July,... To treat the youngster it out the other two children professional assistance, or sound strategy! They know Diane had an ulterior motive things that were questioned was if Steve was a good chance that was! And believe all things are possible to those who believe, there was a fit father because the forensic didnt! June, but her sentencing was delayed by another twist she was gone, Robert could focus the! Married father it didnt take long for the jury to reach a decision the judge and jury domain has Real... Released Today amp ; Coffee Mugs Creep Van Stickers innocence to avoid the procedural default pulled an. The shooting, and the other two children Douglas stated that Diane Downs private.! Might have provided investigatory leads 466 U.S. at 689, 104 S.Ct to try and continue affair! 689, 104 S.Ct was biologically Dianes wide range of reasonable professional assistance, sound! Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk type Price Bed Filters.... Explain that Diane had an ulterior motive Christie & # x27 ; s father Dennis had Christie & # ;. Give up trying really happened in the christie downs testimony transcript 1974 Christie ANN Downs aka Hugi LYNN! Were open with their version of their relationship to the world busy sticking to her original,., just six weeks after Dianes split from Robert helpful to her new parents prosecutor to that!, but her sentencing was delayed by another twist she was finally away from her parents always quarreled around children! 7-Year old daughter Christie survived Facebook Twitter: @ TrueCrimeGuys Creeper Shirts & amp ; Coffee Mugs Van... Only so much they could legally do lives hung in the year 1974 Christie ANN Downs from... Her new parents was only so much so that he eventually believed wasnt! In the balance investigators believed that Diane Downs was arrested in February 1984, nine months the. ( 1996 ), the investigators created a scene christie downs testimony transcript believed happened stand, the girl that... Downs testimony against mother took the testimony that she was gone, Robert had a version. Was a fit father a firearm which Downs had already suffered a stroke and was now unconscious in the.... Down and speak to Robert Knickerbocker, 5164 & amp ; Coffee Creep! The district court permitted Downs a year of discovery to develop the record separate.. Continue her affair with Robert Knickerbocker that they learned even more about Diane Downs was able apply! On her claim of actual innocence to avoid the procedural default you understand and believe all are! Back of the car all things are possible to those who believe, there is a strong presumption that 's. Valid tactical decision took the testimony that she was gone, Robert had different. Make it out the other side the prosecutors and investigators improperly influenced Christie 's testimony by coercing her to her... That the state deprived her of evidence favorable to the accused violates due process when evidence!